Through blogs and comments, patients and experts explore what it takes to find good health care and make the most of it.
Who Gets Preventive Care?
Trudy Lieberman | December 19, 2011
Who doesn't think preventive health care is important? Probably nobody if you ask this question abstractly. But when it comes to getting it--well that's a different matter. Medicare stats show that too few people are getting preventive services even when they are free. It's darn difficult, it seems, to get people to take good care of themselves.
By mid-November, of the four million or so new beneficiaries who signed up for Medicare this year, only 3.6 percent had had their Welcome to Medicare exam. Only 1.7 million of the more than 40 million seniors, most of whom were already on Medicare, had had their 'Annual Wellness Visit.' A poor showing indeed given all the hoopla and hype surrounding the preventive benefits that health reform was supposed to bring to seniors.
To review: All new Medicare beneficiaries are entitled to a free physical exam within the first twelve months that their medical, or Part B, coverage becomes effective. It's a one-time benefit, and Medicare says that seniors are told about the benefit when they sign up. A Medicare spokesperson added that people, who become enrolled in Medicare as a result of receiving Social Security benefits, also automatically receive an enrollment package that discusses the 'Welcome to Medicare exam. What about those haven't yet taken their Social Security benefits or continue to work after they turn 65? Apparently they're on their own to find out. Seniors are also entitled to an Annual Wellness Visit, designed to focus on delivering preventive health services. The exam is free if the doctor accepts Medicare's payment. If the doctor orders tests and procedures not covered under the exam, the patient may incur some expense most likely covered by a Medigap policy or a Medicare Advantage plan.
Despite these free exams designed to catch illness early, barriers remain. One is that doctors themselves don't know the rules or disregard them. A few weeks ago a 72-year-old New York City man on Medicare asked his long-time doctor for a pneumonia vaccination. The doctor refused unless he paid him $300 up front. This vaccination is considered the standard of care for people over age sixty-five and protects against some kinds of pneumonia, a potentially deadly disease. That's why Medicare covers it.
During a subsequent visit, the man again asked for the vaccine and advised the doctor that Medicare covered the injection. This time the doctor said he had no vaccine available, and if he wanted the shot, he should go elsewhere. It was too expensive to keep on hand, he said, because there was no demand from his patients. Maybe that's why he was trying to get his patient to pay out of pocket. Or maybe his patients didn't know they should have the shot. But that raises another question: why wasn't he reminding his patients they needed the vaccination, which would prompt them to get it?
Let's face it. Patients themselves put off getting preventive care perhaps because they are afraid of what it might reveal. Roadblocks like the man encountered make the task of getting the care that much harder. It's easy to blame Medicare for not reminding people more often about what it covers. It's easy to blame the docs for not delivering the right kind of care either for financial reasons or sloppy medical practice.
Patients themselves bear some responsibility too. It's important to read the Medicare Handbook, as dense as it may be, and it's important to challenge your physicians when they don't provide good care. The New York man is reluctant to find a new doctor. Why? Do you know how hard it is at this age to find a new doctor and start over, he says. You can't change doctors as easily as you can go to another restaurant that pads the bill.' It's the old trust factor in medicine. We tend to trust even when we shouldn't.
More Blog Posts by Trudy Lieberman
Trudy Lieberman, a journalist for more than 40 years, is an adjunct associate professor of public health at Hunter College in New York City. She had a long career at Consumer Reports specializing in insurance, health care, health care financing and long-term care. She is a longtime contributor to the Columbia Journalism Review and blogs for its website, CJR.org, about media coverage of health care, Social Security and retirement. As a William Ziff Fellow at the Center for Advancing Health, she contributes regularly to the Prepared Patient Blog. Follow her on twitter @Trudy_Lieberman.
Comments on this post
Please note: CFAH reserves the right to moderate all comments posted to the Prepared Patient Blog. Any inappropriate postings will be removed.
|Medicare Buz » Blog Archive » Mobipocket eBook: "Medicare Handbook, 2012 Edition" by Judith A. Stein / Alfred J. Chiplin Jr. says|
December 20, 2011 at 1:13 PM
[...] To review:Â All new Medicare beneficiaries are entitled to a free physical exam within the first twelve months that their medical, or Part B, coverage becomes effective.Â It’s a one-time benefit, and Medicare says that seniors are told about the benefit when they sign up.Â Â A Medicare spokesperson added that people, who become enrolled in Medicare as a result of receiving Social Security benefits, also automatically receive an enrollment package that discusses the â??Welcome to Medicareâ?? exam.Â What about those haven’t yet taken their Social Security benefits or continue to work after they turn 65?Â Â Apparently they’re on their own to find out.Â Seniors are also entitled to an â??Annual Wellness Visitâ??, designed to focus on delivering preventive health services.Â Â The exam is free if the doctor accepts Medicare’s payment.Â If the doctor orders tests and procedures not covered under the exam, the patient may incur some expense most likely covered by a Medigap policy or a Medicare Advantage plan.Â Source: preparedpatientforum.org [...]
April 20, 2013 at 11:11 AM
Working a 2-4 hour corps at the same on many occasions a week in our Children’s' Expertise Garden, you longing eschew delve fulminous, weed, aerate tarnish, Persuade reliable the garden is healthful and ostentatiously maintained, and more. We've recently built a garden to embolden hard-wearing living and stimulant eating surrounded past the kids in our programs, and from interval to time we basic people with gardening duel to deny the kids say the garden . Our own help doesn't be relevant gardening experience, so we as adults are also looking to learn from our volunteers.
Add Your Comment
|Political Football Season Starts for Medicare
Trudy Lieberman | August 28, 2013
|Making Seniors on Medicare Have More Skin in the Game
Trudy Lieberman | March 26, 2013
|The Government Wants Seniors Out of Bad Medicare Plans
Trudy Lieberman | December 5, 2012
|Trolling for Insurance Prospects on Twitter
Trudy Lieberman | September 18, 2012
Medicare “Doughnut Hole” Causes Seniors to Skip Diabetes Meds
Women in Appalachia Have Higher Rates of Late Stage Breast Cancer